• HOME

  • Bones of Burgos

  • FORUM

  • FRENCH REVOLUTION

    • Origins
    • Events
    • French Revolutionary Wars
    • The Revolution Abroad
    • The Glorious First of June
    • The Battle of Cape St Vincent
    • Occupied Europe
    • Napoleon's Early Life
    • 1793: The Siege of Toulon
    • 1796-7: Napoleon in Italy
    • 1798: Egypt Campagin
    • The War of the Second Coalition
    • The Battle of the Nile
    • Napoleon's Coup
    • War in the West Indies 1793-1801
  • NAPOLEONIC WARS

    • British Politics, 1793-1815
    • Invasion Scares in Britain, 1793-1815
    • The Peace of Amiens, 1802
    • The Redeclaration of War, 1803
    • 1805: The Battle of Trafalgar
    • 1805: Austerlitz
    • 1806: Jena-Auerstedt
    • 1807: Friedland
    • 1809: The Walcheren Expedition
    • 1809: Wagram
    • 1812: Napoleon's Invasion of Russia
    • 1813: Leipzig
    • 1815: Waterloo
    • Expanding Britain's Empire
    • Death, Glory and Legacy
  • PENINSULAR WAR

    • 1808: The War Begins
    • 1809-10: Weathering the Storm
    • 1811: Stalemate
    • 1812: Breaking the Deadlock
    • 1813: Breakout
    • 1814: The Endgame
    • Wellington's Letters
  • LEARN MORE

    • Reviews
    • TEACHER'S ZONE
    • ABOUT
    • CHANNEL
  • Members

  • More

    Use tab to navigate through the menu items.
    To see this working, head to your live site.
    • Categories
    • All Posts
    • My Posts
    tomholmberg
    Mar 23, 2021

    Inniskilling Regiment at Waterloo

    in Waterloo Remembered

    Men, cohesion, and battle: the Inniskilling Regiment at Waterloo.

    Mark Richard Bois

    Univ of Louisville, 2006


    https://ir.library.louisville.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1122&context=etd


    5 comments
    0
    5 Comments

    Share Your ThoughtsSign up to leave a comment.

    J
    john fortune
    Oct 29, 2021

    "Regimental Tradition tends to have only a passing relationship with anything even approaching the truth. Not that the courage of the 27th requires any embroidery." A little harsh perhaps but basically, yes. A rich mix of truth and 'tradition, ' shall we say? - although this particular tale seems to have surfaced quite late, as have cherished tales and traditions in various other regiments. They tend to relate to genuinely meritorious conduct, however, but questioning the embroidery does not reflect on the circumstances from which it grew.

    Like

    J
    john fortune
    Oct 27, 2021

    The casualty toll suffered by the Inniskillings at Mont St Jean has given rise to one fanciful myth, which their descendants, the Royal Irish, are clearly fond of since it featured in three places on their website. The gist of the most commonly repeated version is that Napoleon was so impressed by the dogged stand of the Inniskillings that he observed 'That regiment with the castles on their caps is composed of the most obstinate mules I ever saw; they don’t know when they are beaten’.

    https://www.royal-irish.com/regiment https://www.royal-irish.com/events/the-27th-inniskilling-regiment-of-foot

    Another version reads : I have seen Russian, Prussian and French bravery, but anything to equal the stubborn bravery of the regiment with castles in their caps I never before witnessed'. https://www.royal-irish.com/events/battle-honour-waterloo

    Like
    D
    david Tomlinson
    Oct 29, 2021
    Replying to

    @john fortune Napoleon must have had a particularly cavernous mouth, when you consider how many words were put there by others!


    And excellent eyesight too, as the castles in question were merely engraved on the standard Belgic Shako Plate below the GR. Perhaps he used that magic telescope that saw the Prussians coming.


    Biases and agenda driven history excite comment from many here, but Regimental Tradition tends to have only a passing relationship with anything even approaching the truth. Not that the courage of the 27th requires any embroidery.


    The lack of surviving testimony cannot merely though be put down to attrition. We know PTSD was not to be recognised for many years, but the trauma of that level of casualties was not to be seen for at least another century. The survivor guilt must have been massive, and it's no wonder that those few survivors appear not to have written about it.

    Like

    D
    david Tomlinson
    Mar 24, 2021

    Both the article and @Kevin F. Kiley 's reply has the same difficulty. Besides Lt Drewe's two brief letters in Siborne, there are no available accounts from within the battalion itself, only external observers such as Kincaid and Ross-Llewyn etc.


    Despite 11 volumes of @Gareth Glover 's excellent Waterloo Archive and Dan Harvey's 'A Bloody Day, The Irish at Waterloo' (H Books Cork 2015) there are no more 27th sources to be found, hardly surprising though when you consider the 66% casualty rate. Officers, who provide the majority of exyewitness accounts particularly so, out of 19 by the end of the day 2 were dead and 14 wounded.

    Like

    Kevin F. Kiley
    Mar 23, 2021

    "I felt weary and worn out, less from fatigue than anxiety. Our division, which had stood upwards of 5,000 men at the commencement of the battle, had gradually dwindled down into a solitary line of skirmishers. The 27th Regiment were literally lying dead, in square, a few yards behind us. My horse had received another shot through the leg, and one through the flap of the saddle, which lodged in his body, sending him a step beyond the pension list. The smoke still hung so thick about us that we could see nothing. I walked a little way to each flank, to endeavor to get a glimpse of what was going on; but nothing met my eye, except the mangled remains of men and horses, and I was obliged to return to my post as wise as I went...I had never heard of a battle in which everybody was killed; but this seemed to be an exception, as all were going by turns."-Captain John Kincaid, 95th Rifles.


    The reported casualties for the 1st Bn, 27th Foot, as listed in Scott Bowden's Armies at Waterloo, were:


    Present for Duty:

    Officers: 21.

    Enlisted: 731.


    Killed:

    Officers: 2.

    Enlisted: 103.


    Wounded:

    Officers: 14.

    Enlisted: 360.


    479 out of 752 present were killed or wounded.

    Like
    5 comments
    Similar Posts
    • Regimental History Austrian 41e Infanterie Regiment
    • Regimental Histories
    • The de Watteville Regiment
    tomholmberg
    9h

    The Curse of the Marquis de Sade

    0
    0
    vonlettow
    Jul 08

    Final Images

    11
    1
    tomholmberg
    3d

    COALITIONS AGAINST NAPOLEON

    2
    0
    Hans - Karl Weiß
    Jul 30

    Davout: The Iron Marshal

    4
    0
    vonlettow
    7d

    Napoleon on Campaign: Classic Images of Napoleon at War

    4
    0
    Jonathan North
    5d

    With Murat at Pizzo in 1815

    1
    1
    Hans - Karl Weiß
    May 21

    The Most Irritating Myth of the Napoleonic Era

    5
    0
    Jonathan North
    Jul 25

    Royalistes Contre L'armée (after Waterloo)

    2
    0
    Jonathan North
    Jul 26

    Loyalty in 1815

    3
    1
    Stephen Prentice
    Jun 28

    Anatomy of Glory - going cheap

    3
    2
    Jonathan North
    Jul 22

    British in Provence, 1815

    5
    0
    Hans - Karl Weiß
    Jul 17

    The Greatest Musician of the Napoleonic Era

    3
    0
    ian.chard
    Jul 13

    Portuguese regimental colours

    4
    0
    tomholmberg
    Jul 15

    Lion Monument

    1
    0
    tomholmberg
    Jul 14

    Disabled Veterans of the Napoleonic Wars

    0
    0
    vonlettow
    Mar 02

    Questionable Images?

    63
    2
    tomholmberg
    Jul 11

    Foreign Jack Tars

    0
    0
    Peter O'Brien
    Jun 20, 2021

    Wurttemberg standards 1809-14

    7
    1
    tomholmberg
    Jul 07

    Review: Britain’s Failed Defense of the Netherlands

    1
    0
    tomholmberg
    Jul 06

    Peter Stewart Ney, Again

    2
    0
    Stephen Prentice
    Jul 05

    The Marquise d'Assche

    5
    0
    • Grey Google+ Icon