The thread is still running with a lot of highly interesting contributions. Seemingly due to the unhappy construction of thread presentation, a lot of readers may not be aware of it, I cannot believe they lost interest.
Also the notification by bell or like or following is not working.
Here the link
https://www.thenapoleonicwars.net/forum/general-discussions/was-d-erlon-s-attack-in-line-formation
Mr. John Franklin povided a list of french accounts on TMP in 2011,
some of them are already available on line, but not all of them.
also there is the map from De Bas 1st edition ...
Comte d'Erlon
Donzelot – 2nd Div
d'Arsonval – 3rd Div (Staff officer)
Durutte – 4th Div
Gordon (Staff officer)
Fleuret – 55th
Schmitz – 13th
Gastinieau – 13th
Noguès
Lavoye 29th
Bruno 1st Cavalry Brigade
Dupuy 7th Hussards
Marbot 7th Hussards
Duthilt – 2nd Brigade
Canler – 28th
Veillard – 6th Artillery
Martin – 45th
Brüe de Garoutier
Chapuis 85th
Jacqmin 85th
Bosse – 95th
Bro – 4th Lanciers
Flotard – Ditto
Vernier –